File upload direct to forum?

Discussion in 'Tapatalk for iPhone' started by pellcorp, Sep 27, 2010.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. pellcorp New Member

    Hi,
    The forum I frequent prefers that we upload our images directly to the forum. The upload feature currently in tapatalk only allows uploading via tapatalk hosted - any chance of supporting directly uploading to forum using the file upload functionality of the particular forum (vbulletin 3.8.3)

    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  2. winter Tapatalk Master

    We used to provide this feature but have since disabled it due to overwhelming amount of forums does not allow file upload.
  3. pellcorp New Member

    Surely it would have have made sense to keep this as configuration? Or else fall back to your hosted file upload if the forum does not allow it. Any chance of re-enabling this?


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  4. neounix New Member

    Agreed.

    This should be a configurable option, editable in config.txt:

    Code:
    # cat config.txt
    is_open=1
    guest_okay=1
    reg_url=register.php
    version=vb37_1.7.6
    suffix=
    hide_forum_id=
    shorten_quote=0
    disable_search=0
    disable_latest=0
    disable_pm=0
    allowed_usergroup=
    api_level=3
  5. pellcorp New Member

    Hi,
    In fact I would have thought the forums own - is upload enabled would be enough.

    So pseudo code would be...

    If forum file upload enabled then
    Enable old file upload support
    Else
    Enable new hosted upload support


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  6. neounix New Member

    Should be a (future) option in config.txt like this:

    Code:
    enable_file_upload=0
    (or something like that... )
  7. sophos9 Super Moderator

    That would make good sense, I would prefer images uploaded to be hosted on the same servers :)
  8. melbo Member

    When did we lose it? Maybe I don't understand 'tapatalk hosted'... I uploaded a picture to my forum 2 days ago. 3.8.6
    Someone want to try it? www.survivalmonkey.com/forum
  9. neounix New Member

    If you edit your posts and take a look you should where the img is hosted.....

    Ours is hosted with Tappy....


    Posted from my Samsung Galaxy S mobile.
  10. ashsimmonds New Member

    Add another to the request for re-enabling upload to forum.

    Only reason I got Tapatalk to start with was because it let me post full-size photos on the go to my forum - now it uploads resized versions to a 3rd party site, but most of the time I get a reject message because the file is over 300kb so I end up doing the same dumb old way I used to making Tapatalk now quite pointless.
  11. winter Tapatalk Master

    Are you using iPhone or Android?
  12. ashsimmonds New Member

    iPhone.

    Is there an option somewhere? I saw the other replies and it appears the feature has been removed altogether.
  13. winter Tapatalk Master

    We will look into the 300kb error message issue to avoid it altogether.

    About the attachment vs. hosted image issue. Again this is really one of the many decisions to make to keep improving the app to answer of so many feature requests (in this case, multiple inline images request), while it can also break existing things that some users thought it used to work so well but now it doesn't. Ideally it should let user to decide whether he want to upload it as attachment or hosted images.

    We don't have hidden agenda to move images to host images, the only motive is to empower everyone even their forums do not provide attachment service, to have a chance to share images via smartphone. We can certainly add this back in the future as we move forward with the Tapatalk API.
    :)
  14. neounix New Member

    That's good to hear....

    I think many forums are like us. We don't want our images hosted elsewhere. We cannot have our attachments, images, files, etc. hosted on a service that may, or may not, be around in 1 year, 2 years, 5 years, or even 20 years.

    If we depended on Taptalk for images, then if your service ever changed, or you decided you wanted to charge some high fees for it, then all the URLs and image attachments would be lost to forum users. We cannot have that.

    So, you say you don't have a hidden agenda. Fine. I accept it. But you need to make these options configurable by the forum owner.

    FYI, because of these issues, we have already removed tapatalkdetect.js from our site, until such issues are resolved. We are not going to remove the application from the forum yet, and will wait and see if the direction, with regard to a number of issues, improves.

    www.unix.com
  15. pellcorp New Member

    Can this be restored in next release? If not can you provide an ETA. This seems to have high priority for many forum owners and users
  16. melbo Member

    I want control of our images too. We like to keep everything stable and unchanging and I rarely let us rely on a 3rd party.
  17. tfs New Member

    This was a bad idea. Now I can't upload images to my forum, but I have to host them on someone elses server? Not acceptable. I don't give anyone else the right to have a copy of my photographs. But even if I don't implicitly give ownership of a photo to TapaTalk, (hosted at tapa.tk - wherever that is) just the fact that I'm uploading them to your server means that I'm losing ownership.

    I'm using an iPhone 3GS, IOS4.1. This started when I updated my SMF 2.0 RC3 forum from Tapatalk 1.1 to Tapatalk 1.2. Now I'm no longer able to upload images and attach them to messages. Instead they are uploaded to "tapa.tk". I'm assuming Tapatalk owns that server, but it's really not a good idea. Please give us a configuration option.
  18. PanosI New Member

    Not happy at all :mad::mad::mad:

    I want back the old way to upload pics to my forums....
  19. PanosI New Member

    Any news about changing the way as it was before regarding the upload of the pics ?????
  20. DoTheChop New Member

    Add one more to this list.

    Pictures uploaded need to be hosted on the forum's server, not on Tapatalk's.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.